Affiliate disclosure: This article contains an affiliate link. JewishBabysitter.com may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Ask about current training
Ask which organization provided the course, when it was completed and whether the certification is current. Parents may request to see documentation. Training should never be assumed simply because a sitter has experience.
Discuss realistic situations
- What would you do if a child began choking?
- When would you call 911 before calling a parent?
- How would you respond to a severe allergic reaction?
- What would you do if a child fell near a pool?
- How would you keep the other children safe during an emergency?
The goal is not to conduct a medical examination. Listen for calm decision-making, a willingness to call for help and an understanding that emergencies should not be hidden.
Prepare the home
Keep Going First Aid
An organized first aid kit can help families and caregivers find basic supplies quickly when minor injuries happen.
Browse Family First Aid Kits →Explain your child's needs
Tell the sitter about allergies, asthma, seizures, medications or other relevant conditions before confirming the job. Provide written instructions from the appropriate medical professional when needed, and decide whether the responsibility is suitable for that caregiver.
Prepare the home together
Even a trained sitter needs the correct address, parent numbers, emergency contacts and the location of first aid supplies. Review pool barriers, alarms, pets and exits. Clear preparation supports training rather than replacing it.
This guide is educational and is not medical or certification advice.
Understand what the credential actually covers
Ask whether the course included infant, child or adult skills relevant to your family, whether it involved hands-on practice and when the sitter last refreshed the material. A card's existence does not answer how a person will respond under pressure. A parent can ask to see a current certificate and, if needed, confirm its status with the issuing organization. Do not imply that a first aid kit or a short article substitutes for training.
Give the sitter the child's actual care plan
For allergies or other conditions, ask the child's clinician what written instructions and training a caregiver needs. Show where prescribed supplies are kept and review who is authorized and willing to use them. If the sitter is unsure about a task, choose a different care arrangement or get the needed training before the visit. Share the home's address and a second emergency contact even with a familiar sitter.
Listen for the right escalation
In an interview, a useful answer describes getting immediate help for a serious emergency, keeping other children safe and informing parents as soon as it is safe. It should not rely on “I would look it up” while delaying an emergency call. Ask how the sitter would react if a parent cannot be reached, how she would explain the location to responders and whether she has any responsibility she would decline.
Complete the conversation with the written contact sheet and a tour of the home. This is an interview aid, not a test of medical knowledge or a promise about an individual sitter's credentials.
Ask in a way that does not feel like an exam
Many good sitters freeze when an interview starts to sound like a test. Frame the safety questions as part of getting to know your home. For example: "We ask everyone the same few safety questions, and there are no trick answers. I just want to understand how you'd handle things here." Then start with the easier, practical questions, such as when her course was and what it covered, before moving to the scenarios. You will hear more honest answers, including "I'm not sure," which is far more useful than a confident guess.
Turn general questions into questions about your house
Once you know her training, ask how it would play out in your specific home. "Our bedrooms are upstairs and the kitchen is downstairs. If the baby were choking while the older two were in the bath, what would you do with them?" "We have a pool behind a gate. If you heard a splash, where would the other children go?" "If you needed to call 911, could you give the address and directions without looking it up?" These questions show whether she has thought about managing a whole house of children in a crisis, not only one child.
What a reassuring answer sounds like
You are not looking for medical detail. A helpful answer usually includes three things: she would act on her training right away, she would get emergency help without waiting to reach a parent, and she would keep the other children safe and together. For example, a thoughtful sitter might say she would put her phone on speaker while she helped, keep the older children in one room where she could see them, and call the parents once help was on the way. An answer that starts with "I'd text you first and see what you think" is a reason to talk through the plan again before you hire.
Teens and newer sitters
A teenage sitter from your neighborhood or shul may be wonderful with children and still have little formal training. You can ask whether she would be willing to take a course for babysitters, and whether she has looked after infants or only older children. Keep early visits simple: a short evening, children who are already asleep or older, a nearby adult who will definitely be home, and the pool closed. Expand the responsibilities as she gains experience. Our guide to finding a sitter in Phoenix covers references and trial visits.
Questions for Shabbos and Yom Tov jobs
On Shabbos and holidays, parents may be out of reach by phone and many homes do not keep phones within easy reach. Ask the sitter where she would keep a phone for emergencies and make sure the answer fits your family's practice and the house layout. Tell her plainly that calling 911 in a real emergency is always right, on any day, and that nobody will be upset with her for doing it. If she keeps Shabbos herself, ask whether she has any questions about that, and suggest she ask her own rav if so. The Shabbat and holiday guide has more on planning those visits.
Revisit the conversation when life changes
A safety conversation is not a one-time box to tick. Come back to it when a certificate is due for renewal, when a new baby arrives, when a child receives a new diagnosis or prescription, when you move into a home with a pool, or when the sitter starts driving your children. Each of those changes the skills and instructions she needs. A short check-in at the start of summer is also a good habit in the Valley, when pool and heat questions become daily ones.
Common mistakes
- Accepting "I'm certified" without asking what the course covered or when.
- Asking only about one child, when the hard part is managing all of them at once.
- Treating a nervous answer as a failure instead of a chance to talk through the plan.
- Never repeating the conversation after a new baby, a new condition or a move.
- Leaving a sitter unsure whether she may call 911 before reaching a parent.
Frequently asked questions
Is it rude to ask to see a sitter's CPR certificate?
No. Most experienced sitters expect it. Ask politely, explain that you ask everyone, and thank her for showing it.
What if a sitter I like has no CPR training?
You can ask whether she would be willing to take a course, and in the meantime keep her visits to simpler situations. Decide whether the job fits her current training before confirming.
Should I ask a family member who babysits the same questions?
Yes, gently. Grandparents and older cousins benefit from the same walk-through, especially about the address, the pool rule and when to call 911.