The best activity plan is one a babysitter can use without searching through cupboards or learning a complicated project. Start with familiar materials, give children a little choice, and leave room for ordinary play. For a Jewish household, shared stories and family traditions can be part of the visit without turning it into a lesson.
Set out three choices, not a full schedule
Leave a small basket with a favorite picture book, a simple game and drawing supplies. Tell the sitter which items are appropriate for each child and which need close supervision. Avoid small pieces around children who still put objects in their mouths. Ask the sitter to offer two options at a time: “Would you like a story or drawing first?”
Make a read-aloud interactive
Choose a book your child already enjoys. The sitter can pause to ask what might happen next, invite the child to describe a picture, or let a confident reader take a turn. A story about kindness or helping others can lead naturally to a conversation about a good deed. Give the sitter the pronunciation of unfamiliar names rather than expecting them to know it.
Use Jewish themes only where they fit
On an ordinary weekday, a child might draw a favorite Shabbat memory, match Alef-Bet cards the family already owns, or tell a story about a holiday. These are options, not expectations. Explain your child’s level of familiarity and the customs you want followed. For Shabbat or a holiday, confirm permitted activities with the family before the visit; do not assume crafts or writing are appropriate.
Plan for different ages and energy levels
A toddler may need short stretches of play and a familiar song. An older child might prefer a puzzle, pretend shop or turn-taking game. Siblings do not have to complete the same activity. Give the sitter a quieter alternative and a clear rule for any movement game, including rooms or furniture that are off limits.
Keep the cleanup simple
Use washable supplies you have already approved, protect the table if necessary and show where finished work belongs. Leave scissors, glue and messy materials out of reach unless you have agreed on supervised use. Five minutes of putting materials away can become a predictable transition to snack or bedtime.
Leave a fallback for a reluctant child
It is fine if a child would rather build with familiar toys than follow the activity menu. Ask the sitter to offer a calm alternative instead of forcing participation. Share any comfort object, favorite phrase or routine that helps your child settle.
A sample activity basket by age
One basket per child, or one shared basket with a few things for each age, lets the sitter start an activity in under a minute. For example:
- Toddlers: two board books, chunky crayons and a large pad, stacking cups or big blocks, and a familiar song the sitter can sing. Nothing small enough to fit in a mouth.
- Ages 4 to 7: a picture book, a simple matching or memory game, stickers and paper, and a few dress-up pieces for pretend play.
- Ages 8 to 12: a chapter book they are already reading, a card or board game for two, a puzzle and a notebook for drawing comics or writing a story.
Rotate one or two items every few weeks so the basket still feels new. A child who has seen the same game every visit will drift back to asking for a screen.
Ideas built around the Jewish week
A weekday visit can echo the rhythm of a Jewish home without becoming a lesson. On a Thursday or Friday morning, children might draw place cards for the Shabbos table, color a picture of something from the week's parsha that they learned in school, or fold napkins. A child can decorate a paper tzedakah box and put in a coin the parents left out. Younger children enjoy a picture chart of brachos for common snacks, if that matches your family's practice. Ask the sitter not to use real family ritual objects, such as a kiddush cup or a special menorah, unless a parent has set them out for that purpose.
Shabbos afternoons: activities that usually fit
A Shabbos sitter needs a separate list, because many everyday activities are set aside. Families often keep a "Shabbos shelf" with games and books that fit their practice, so the sitter does not have to decide. Common choices include picture books and read-aloud stories, some board and card games, puzzles, pretend play with dolls or figures, and singing Shabbos songs the children know. Practices differ from home to home on things like certain building toys, ball games or games that involve writing, so write your family's list down and, if you are unsure, ask your rav. Our Shabbat guide covers the rest of the afternoon.
Movement for indoor days
From late spring into fall in the Valley, much of the active play has to happen indoors. Give the sitter permission for one or two movement games and name the room. A hallway obstacle course with couch cushions, freeze dance with singing instead of a speaker, animal walks across the living room, or a "follow the leader" around the house can all fill twenty minutes. Say which furniture is off limits and whether jumping on beds is ever allowed. Our heat safety guide explains why the backyard may be closed in the afternoon.
Big families: set up stations
When several children of different ages are home, one shared activity often ends in a quarrel. Try stations instead: the older children at the table with a game, a middle child on the floor with a puzzle, and the toddler with the sitter and a book. Every so often the sitter calls "switch." Older children can also be given a small helping role, such as reading a short book to a younger sibling, which keeps them busy and gives the sitter a free hand.
Ending an activity without a fight
Transitions are where screen-free plans often fall apart. Ask the sitter to give a short warning ("Two more turns, then we clean up for snack") and to make cleanup part of the game, such as racing to put the blocks away before a song ends. Leave a container for unfinished artwork so a child knows it will be kept for the parents to see.
Common mistakes
- Leaving a cupboard full of options instead of a short, ready basket.
- Expecting a weekday craft plan to work on Shabbos.
- Choosing games with small pieces when a toddler is in the room.
- Asking siblings of very different ages to all play the same thing.
- Making the activity menu so formal that a child's own play feels like breaking the rules.
Frequently asked questions
What if my child only wants a screen?
Ask the sitter to offer two concrete choices instead of a yes-or-no, and to start the first activity alongside the child. If you do allow some screen time, write exactly when and how long.
Can the sitter do a Chanukah or other holiday craft?
Yes on a weekday, if you set out the supplies and it is not on Shabbos or Yom Tov. Our Chanukah guide has a paper menorah craft that needs no real fire.
Does the sitter need to know Hebrew to read to my children?
No. Give her English books or let a confident older child read the Hebrew parts. Write down the pronunciation of any names or words she is likely to see.
Optional resource: ModernTribe
If you want to purchase something for future visits, ModernTribe offers Jewish-themed family items. Choose an age-appropriate option that fits your household; a new purchase is not needed to use this guide.
Explore Jewish family activities at ModernTribe