Hiring · Safety

Questions to Ask a Babysitter Before You Hire: A Parent Checklist

A short, friendly conversation before the first job tells you more than any profile. Here are the questions worth asking, why each one matters, and what a good answer sounds like.

A mother and a teenage babysitter talking at a kitchen table while a toddler plays with blocks nearby

Most parents hire a sitter on gut feeling and a friend's recommendation. Both matter. But a fifteen-minute chat, ideally with your kids nearby, lets you see how the sitter talks, listens and handles a small surprise. Use the questions below as a menu, not a script. Pick the ones that fit your family.

Experience and ages

  • What ages have you cared for, and for how long? Watching a newborn is very different from managing three school-age kids at bedtime.
  • Have you cared for more than one child at a time? How many? Ask for real examples, not "lots."
  • What do you like most about babysitting? You are listening for warmth and enthusiasm, not a perfect answer.
  • Can you give me two families I can call? A good sitter is happy to share references. When you call, ask what the sitter did well and whether they would hire them again.

Safety first

  • Are you certified in CPR and first aid? When did you train? Every sitter who works through JewishBabysitter.com is CPR and First Aid certified, but it is still worth asking about their training. See our guide to CPR and first aid questions.
  • What would you do if a child was choking? Had a fever? Got a cut? Listen for calm, clear steps and when they would call 911 and you.
  • Have you ever handled an emergency while babysitting? A thoughtful answer shows judgment.
  • Will you keep your phone charged and answer when I call? Also ask how they use their phone while working.
  • Do you drive? Would you drive my kids? Only allow it if you have discussed car seats, routes and your own comfort level.

In the Valley, two extra safety topics matter:

  • Pools. Ask: "What are your rules around the pool?" The right answer includes constant supervision and never leaving children near water. Our pool safety guide has a full checklist.
  • Heat. Ask how they keep kids safe outdoors in summer. See heat safety for babysitters.

Your home, your rules

  • How do you handle bedtime when a child refuses to sleep?
  • What do you do when siblings fight?
  • How do you feel about screens? Can you follow our limits? Our screen-free activities guide has ideas to share.
  • How do you handle discipline? Make clear what is and is not allowed in your home.
  • Are you comfortable with pets? If you have a dog or cat, ask directly. See babysitting with pets.

Shabbos, Yom Tov and kashrus

For frum and traditional homes, these questions prevent most misunderstandings:

  • Have you babysat in a kosher home? Do you know the difference between fleishig and milchig dishes? Our printable kosher kitchen cards make it easy to explain your kitchen.
  • Are you comfortable on Shabbos or Yom Tov? Discuss phones, lights, the oven and the eruv ahead of time. See our Shabbat and holiday babysitting guide and babysitting in a frum home.
  • Can you bring your own snacks, and are they kosher? Decide what is allowed in the house.

Allergies and medicine

  • Have you cared for a child with food allergies? If your child has one, walk through the plan in writing. FARE offers a free Food Allergy and Anaphylaxis Emergency Care Plan form a doctor can sign.
  • Are you comfortable giving medicine? Give exact written instructions for any medicine, with the dose and time.

Practical details

  • What is your rate, and does it change for more kids, late nights or holidays? Our Phoenix and Scottsdale rate guide shows typical ranges.
  • How much notice do you need, and what is your cancellation policy?
  • When do you need to be home, and how will you get there? Plan safe transportation for late nights.

Watch the first meeting

Some of the best information is not in the answers. Notice whether the sitter:

  • greets your children by name and gets down to their level,
  • asks you questions too (a good sign of care),
  • puts the phone away while you talk, and
  • seems patient when a child interrupts.

Red flags

  • Vague answers about past jobs or no references at all.
  • Brushing off safety questions, especially about the pool.
  • Pressure to be paid in advance or to skip the meeting.
  • Reluctance to follow your house rules.

Set them up to succeed

After you hire, give the sitter a written plan: phone numbers, address, allergies, bedtimes and house rules. Our printable emergency contact sheet and babysitter safety checklist cover the essentials. For the first job, try a short daytime shift while you are nearby.

General parenting information, written from a parent's point of view and last reviewed November 21, 2026. It is not legal, medical or halachic advice.

Frequently asked questions

What should I ask a babysitter in an interview?

Ask about the ages they have cared for, CPR and first aid training, what they would do in an emergency, how they handle bedtime and sibling fights, screen rules, pool and heat safety, and for Jewish homes, Shabbos and kashrus. Ask for references too.

How do I check a babysitter's references?

Call at least two families. Ask how long the sitter worked for them, what ages they watched, how they handled problems, and whether the family would hire them again.

Should a babysitter know CPR?

It is a strong plus. Every sitter who works through JewishBabysitter.com is CPR and First Aid certified, and it is still worth asking when they trained.

What are red flags when hiring a babysitter?

Vague answers about past jobs, no references, brushing off safety questions, asking to be paid in advance, or reluctance to follow your house rules.

How do I explain a kosher kitchen to a new sitter?

Show them the meat and dairy dishes, label cabinets if you can, and leave written rules. Our printable kosher kitchen cards make this easy.

Sources

Ready to line up care? Tell us about your family, your dates and the kind of help you need, and we'll take it from there. Request a babysitter.